Consider the following for the next ten (10) items that follow :
Each item contains a Question followed by two Statements. Answer each item using the following instructions :
Choose option
- (a)
- If the Question can be answered by one of the Statements alone, but not by the other.
- (b)
- If the Question can be answered by either Statement alone.
- (c)
- If the Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered by using either Statement alone.
- (d)
- If the Question cannot be answered even by using both Statements together.
Let , , and be positive integers.
Question : Which one of , , , is closest to the product ?
- I
- II
- is not the smallest.
Show answer & solutionHide answer & solution
Option C
Approach
Each factor is at most the product, so the closest to the product is the largest of the four numbers. Then see which statements fix the largest.
Step-by-step solution
- 1for each factor , so is smallest for the largest
Why: Each number is a positive integer, so the product is at least as large as every factor. The closest factor is therefore the largest one.
- 2Statement I: , but is unknown. The largest is or
Why: Nothing compares with , so I alone is not enough.
- 3Statement II: nothing about the order of , , follows from it alone
Why: II says only that some other number is smaller than . This gives no largest number.
- 4I and II together: only can be smaller than , so and is the largest
Why: From I, and are larger than . II says some number is smaller than , so it must be . The order is then fully known.
Common mistakes
Option A
Took statement I alone as enough because is the largest of
Option B
No route reaches 'either alone': statement II gives no order at all.
Option D
Thought the two statements do not settle where stands. But 'c is not the smallest' with forces to be the smallest.

