Directions for the following 4 (four) items :
Read the following four passages and answer the items that follow. Your answers to these items should be based on the passages only.
Passage - 1
Researchers simulated street lighting on artificial grassland plots containing pea-aphids, sap-sucking insects, at night. These were exposed to two different types of light — a white light similar to newer commercial LED lights and an amber light similar to sodium street lamps. The low intensity amber light was shown to inhibit, rather than induce, flowering in a wild plant of the pea family which is a source of food for the pea-aphids in grasslands. The number of aphids was also significantly suppressed under the light treatment due to the limited amount of food available.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most critical inference that can be made from the passage given above ?
Show answer & solutionHide answer & solution
Option B
Why
The study lit grassland plots as street lamps light them at night. The amber light stopped a wild pea plant from flowering, and the aphids that feed on it fell in number for want of food. Artificial light at night harmed the plant and, through it, the animals: light pollution can damage a whole ecosystem. The passage says nothing about the harm being permanent, and D states the plant-to-aphid chain directly, so D is also defensible.
Proof
Researchers simulated street lighting on artificial grassland plots … The low intensity amber light was shown to inhibit, rather than induce, flowering in a wild plant of the pea family which is a source of food for the pea-aphids in grasslands. The number of aphids was also significantly suppressed
About the other options
Option A
Not in the passage: only low intensity amber light is reported; there is no comparison with high intensity light.
Option C
Not in the passage: it reports the effect of amber light only, not how white light affects flowering.
Option D
Also defensibleDefensible: it states the chain from plant to aphids directly, while 'permanent' in B is not in the passage. The official key prefers B as the wider point about street lighting.