Convention
Syllogisms: a 'may' or 'possibility' conclusion needs just one diagram where it is true
Logical Reasoning • Syllogisms
Statement
Most conclusions say something is certain, and must hold in every diagram. A conclusion with 'may', 'can be' or 'is a possibility' says only that something could be so. It follows if you can draw at least one diagram that obeys all the statements and makes it true. It fails only when the statements force the opposite, for example 'all A are B' makes 'some A may not be B' false.
How to use it
- 1Spot the word 'may', 'can' or 'possibility' in the conclusion.
- 2Check whether any statement directly forces the opposite.
- 3If nothing forces the opposite, draw one diagram where the conclusion is true: it follows.
Worked example
Statements: Some pens are books. All books are bags. Does 'Some pens may not be bags' follow? Does 'Some books may not be bags' follow?
Step-by-step
- 1No statement links pens to bags for all pens; a pen outside the book circle can sit outside bags.
Why: One diagram is enough for a possibility.
- 2So 'some pens may not be bags' follows.
- 3'All books are bags' forces every book inside bags, so 'some books may not be bags' does not follow.
Why: A definite statement rules out the opposite possibility.
Answer
The first follows; the second does not.
Watch out
Do not apply the 'true in every diagram' test to a 'may' conclusion; that test is for certain conclusions. A possibility fails when a definite statement rules it out.
Builds on
Also known as
possibility conclusion, may be conclusion, some may not be, can be in syllogism