Procedure
Syllogisms: a conclusion follows only if no diagram breaks it
Logical Reasoning • Syllogisms
Statement
Treat each group as a circle. 'All A are B' puts circle A inside B. 'No A is B' keeps them apart. 'Some A are B' makes them overlap at least a little. A conclusion follows only if it is true in every drawing that obeys all the statements. So for each conclusion, try to draw a picture that obeys the statements but breaks the conclusion; if you can, it does not follow. Chains work: if some A are B and all B are C, then the A that are B are also C, so some A are C.
How to use it
- 1Draw the tightest picture the statements force.
- 2For each conclusion, look for a second picture, still obeying the statements, where it is false.
- 3'Some A are B' and 'some B are A' say the same; 'all A are B' does not give 'all B are A'.
Worked example
Statements: All cats are pets. No pet is wild. Does 'No cat is wild' follow? Does 'Some pets are cats' follow?
Step-by-step
- 1Cats circle sits inside pets; pets circle is apart from wild.
Why: Draw what the statements force.
- 2Cats are inside pets, so they are apart from wild: 'No cat is wild' is true in every drawing.
Why: No picture can break it.
- 3Every cat is a pet, so the cats circle overlaps pets: 'Some pets are cats' follows.
Why: 'All A are B' gives 'some B are A' when A exists.
Answer
Both follow.
Watch out
A conclusion that is merely possible, true in one drawing, does not follow. 'No A is B' and 'all A are C' do not tell whether any B is a C.