Directions for the following 7 (seven) items :
Read the following five passages and answer the items that follow. Your answers to these items should be based on the passages only.
Passage—1
Private investment in general is volatile. Foreign private investment is more volatile because the available investment avenues are significantly greater (i.e., the entire world). Therefore, the responsibility of providing employment cannot be left to Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). The current FDI inflows are volatile over time and across sectors and regions, which is a necessary consequence of their search for the highest returns. The adverse consequences are unstable employment and an accentuation of income and regional inequalities. A probable positive consequence of foreign investment is the inflow of new technology and its subsequent diffusion. However, the technology diffusion is not at all certain because the existing state of physical and human capital in India may prove inadequate for the diffusion.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
- 1
- Relying on foreign investment in the long run is not an economically sound policy.
- 2
- Policies must be undertaken to reduce volatility in foreign private investment.
- 3
- Policies must be undertaken to strengthen domestic private investment.
- 4
- Public investment should be given priority over private investment.
- 5
- Substantial public investment in education and health should be undertaken.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
Show answer & solutionHide answer & solution
Option B
Why
The passage says foreign investment is too volatile, that is unstable, to carry the job of providing employment. Its technology spreads only if India's physical and human capital is good enough. 1 valid: employment cannot be left to foreign investment, so long-run reliance on it is unsound. 2 not valid: volatility is a necessary result of foreign investors seeking the highest returns, so policy cannot simply remove it. 3 valid: foreign investment is more volatile than other private investment, so domestic private investment is the steadier source to build up. 4 not valid: the passage never ranks public investment above private. 5 valid: India's human capital may be too weak to absorb new technology, so it needs investment in education and health.
Proof
Foreign private investment is more volatile … Therefore, the responsibility of providing employment cannot be left to Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). … which is a necessary consequence of their search for the highest returns. … the existing state of physical and human capital in India may prove inadequate for the diffusion.
About the other options
Option A
Includes 2 and 4: the volatility is a necessary result of seeking returns, and public investment is never ranked first.
Option C
Includes 2 and 4, which the passage does not support, and drops 1.
Option D
Drops 1 and 5: the passage rejects relying on foreign investment and points to weak human capital.