Consider the following statements :
- 1
- ‘Right to the City’ is an agreed human right and the UN-Habitat monitors the commitments made by each country in this regard.
- 2
- ‘Right to the City’ gives every occupant of the city the right to reclaim public spaces and public participation in the city.
- 3
- ‘Right to the City’ means that the State cannot deny any public service or facility to the unauthorized colonies in the city.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Show answer & solutionHide answer & solution
Option D
Why
1 — Wrong. The 'Right to the City' is an idea, from the French thinker Henri Lefebvre, not an agreed human right in any treaty. UN-Habitat's New Urban Agenda (2016) mentions it as 'cities for all', but countries have made no binding commitment on it for UN-Habitat to monitor. 2 — Correct. The idea gives every person living in a city the right to use and reclaim public spaces and to take part in decisions about the city. 3 — Correct. As the idea is understood, it belongs to every resident, whatever their legal status. So the State cannot deny public services to people just because their colony is unauthorised.
Exam-hall approach
Statement 2 is the safest: it is the plain meaning of the phrase. It appears only in C and D. Then 'agreed human right ... monitors the commitments made by each country' claims too much for an idea, so statement 1 falls and D remains. The word 'any' in statement 3 looks like a sign of a false statement, but here it does not decide the question.
About the other options
Option A
Statement 1 is wrong: the Right to the City is an idea, not an agreed human right that UN-Habitat monitors.
Option B
Leaves out statement 2, which is the core meaning of the idea.
Option C
Contains statement 1, which is wrong.