Skip to content
Theorem

Swap a liquid back and forth, end with equal volumes: each holds as much of the other as it lost

Quantitative Aptitude • Averages and Mixtures

Statement

Start with of milk in one container and of water in another. Move some liquid across and the same volume back, so each container again holds . The milk container has lost some milk, say , and its volume is back to , so the gap was filled by exactly of water. That missing of milk can only be in the other container. So each container holds the same amount of the other liquid, and the proportions match.

How to use it

  1. 1Check that both containers end with the same volume they started with.
  2. 2Then the amount of 'foreign' liquid in each is the same, with no calculation.
  3. 3If a number is needed, work out one container only and use the match for the other.

Worked example

A jug has 50 ml of juice and a glass 50 ml of water. 10 ml of juice is poured into the glass, mixed, and 10 ml poured back. Is there more water in the jug or more juice in the glass?

Step-by-step

  1. 1
    Both end with 50 ml, as at the start.

    Why: Equal volumes are what make the swap balance.

  2. 2
    Whatever juice the jug is missing was replaced by the same amount of water, and that juice is in the glass.
  3. 3
    So they are equal.

Answer

Equal amounts.

Watch out

The rule needs both containers to end with their starting volumes. If unequal amounts are moved, work it out step by step instead.

Also known as

milk and water exchange, back and forth transfer, equal contamination

Appears in past papers

2022