Skip to content
Technique

Who did it: assume each person in turn and test every statement

Logical Reasoning • Truth and Lies

Statement

When exactly one person is the culprit, there are only as many cases as people. In each case every statement becomes simply true or false. A case survives if it fits the rule the question gives (for example 'only one is lying'). If the question gives no rule about truth, every case survives unless a statement is impossible on its own, and the culprit cannot be found.

How to use it

  1. 1List the people; assume each one is the culprit in turn.
  2. 2In each case, mark every statement true or false.
  3. 3Compare with the truth rule stated in the question. Keep the cases that fit.
  4. 4One case left: that is the culprit. Several left: it cannot be concluded.

Worked example

One of A and B broke a cup. A says 'B broke it'. B says 'A broke it'. Exactly one of them is lying. Who broke it?

Step-by-step

  1. 1
    If A broke it: A's statement is false, B's is true. One liar: fits.
  2. 2
    If B broke it: A's statement is true, B's is false. One liar: also fits.

    Why: Both cases obey the rule.

  3. 3
    Two cases survive.

Answer

It cannot be concluded.

Watch out

Bringing in a rule the question does not state, such as 'the culprit always lies', is the usual mistake: it can remove cases the question leaves open.

Also known as

truth and lies, who is guilty, suspect statements

Appears in past papers

2025