Technique
Who did it: assume each person in turn and test every statement
Logical Reasoning • Truth and Lies
Statement
When exactly one person is the culprit, there are only as many cases as people. In each case every statement becomes simply true or false. A case survives if it fits the rule the question gives (for example 'only one is lying'). If the question gives no rule about truth, every case survives unless a statement is impossible on its own, and the culprit cannot be found.
How to use it
- 1List the people; assume each one is the culprit in turn.
- 2In each case, mark every statement true or false.
- 3Compare with the truth rule stated in the question. Keep the cases that fit.
- 4One case left: that is the culprit. Several left: it cannot be concluded.
Worked example
One of A and B broke a cup. A says 'B broke it'. B says 'A broke it'. Exactly one of them is lying. Who broke it?
Step-by-step
- 1If A broke it: A's statement is false, B's is true. One liar: fits.
- 2If B broke it: A's statement is true, B's is false. One liar: also fits.
Why: Both cases obey the rule.
- 3Two cases survive.
Answer
It cannot be concluded.
Watch out
Bringing in a rule the question does not state, such as 'the culprit always lies', is the usual mistake: it can remove cases the question leaves open.
Also known as
truth and lies, who is guilty, suspect statements