Skip to content
Convention

'All A are B' and 'Some A are not B' are opposites: exactly one of them is true

Logical Reasoning • Syllogisms

Statement

'All A are B' and 'Some A are not B' cannot both be true and cannot both be false. The same holds for 'No A is B' and 'Some A are B'. Knowing one statement of a pair fixes the other; it says nothing about the other pair.

How to use it

  1. 1Find the statement that is the exact opposite of the one given. Its truth value is the reverse.
  2. 2For any statement outside that pair, ask whether a picture exists where it is true and another where it is false. If both exist, it cannot be decided.

Worked example

Given that 'Some fruits are not sweet' is true, what can be said about 'All fruits are sweet' and 'No fruit is sweet'?

Step-by-step

  1. 1
    'All fruits are sweet' is the opposite of the given statement, so it is false.

    Why: One fruit that is not sweet is enough to break 'all'.

  2. 2
    'No fruit is sweet' may be true (every fruit sour) or false (some sweet, some sour).

    Why: Both pictures fit the given statement, so this one is not decided.

Answer

'All fruits are sweet' is false; 'No fruit is sweet' cannot be decided.

Watch out

'Some A are not B' does not mean 'Some A are B'. Reading 'some' as 'some but not all' makes candidates wrongly decide the other pair.

Also known as

contradictory statements, square of opposition, all versus some not, negation of all

Appears in past papers

2017