Technique
Tournament puzzles: every match hands out a fixed total of points
Logical Reasoning • Puzzles and Distribution
Statement
With 2 points for a win, 1 each for a draw and 0 for a loss, every match gives out 2 points in total. So total points number of matches. A team's points fix its mix of wins and draws: with two matches, 3 points is a win and a draw, 2 points is two draws or a win and a loss, 1 point is a draw and a loss. Combine these into full tables of results, then test each table against any extra facts, such as goals.
How to use it
- 1Check that the points add to 2 per match.
- 2Write each team's possible mix of wins, draws and losses.
- 3Build the few full result tables that fit every team.
- 4Test each table against the other facts (goals scored, scores) and keep those that survive.
Worked example
Teams A, B, C play each other once (2 for a win, 1 for a draw). A gets 4 points, B 1 and C 1. What were the results?
Step-by-step
- 13 matches give 6 points: .
- 2A's 4 points from two matches: two wins.
Why: Only two wins give 4.
- 3B and C each lost to A, so their 1 point each comes from drawing with each other.
Answer
A beat B, A beat C, and B drew with C.
Watch out
Forgetting that one team's two cases (two draws, or a win and a loss) each make a different table loses a case; so does not testing every table against the goals.
Also known as
points table, round robin, league table puzzle