Convention
'A only if B' means B is needed: one way to get A without B makes it false
Logical Reasoning • Conditional Statements
Statement
'A only if B' says B is needed for A: whenever A is true, B is true. It does not say B is enough. 'A if B' is the claim that B is enough. So to test an 'only if' claim, look for a way A can happen without B. One such way makes the claim false. Showing that B does lead to A proves only the 'if' part.
How to use it
- 1Spot the words 'only if', 'only when' or 'not ... unless': they claim that something is needed.
- 2Ask: can the result be reached without that condition? Try one other fact or one other case.
- 3If you find one, the 'only if' claim is false, even when the condition would also give the result.
Worked example
Claim: 'You can reach the station on time only if you take a taxi.' The bus also reaches the station on time. Is the claim true?
Step-by-step
- 1The claim says a taxi is needed to be on time.
Why: 'Only if' names something needed, not something enough.
- 2The bus gets you there on time without a taxi.
Why: One way without the condition is all the test needs.
- 3So the taxi is not needed, and the claim is false, even though a taxi would also be on time.
Answer
False: being on time does not need the taxi.
Watch out
The common slip is to check only that the condition works and call the claim true. That proves 'if', not 'only if'.
Also known as
necessary condition, only if, only when, necessary versus sufficient, unless