Skip to content
Convention

'Either A or B': if one is false, the other is true

Logical Reasoning • Conditional Statements

Statement

'Either A or B' says at least one of A and B happens. So if A does not happen, B must; and if B does not happen, A must. The valid pairs are (not A, then B) and (not B, then A). Knowing A happens does not tell whether B happens, because the statement does not say both cannot happen.

How to use it

  1. 1Name the two parts, A and B.
  2. 2A valid pair starts by denying one part and ends by stating the other.
  3. 3Reject any pair that starts by stating a part, or ends by denying one.

Worked example

'Either the shop is closed or the light is on.' The light is not on. What follows?

Step-by-step

  1. 1
    A: the shop is closed. B: the light is on.
  2. 2
    Not B is given, so A follows.

    Why: At least one part must be true; the light part is false.

Answer

The shop is closed.

Watch out

Going from 'A is true' to 'B is false' is the trap: either-or forbids both being false, not both being true, unless the question says only one can happen.

Also known as

either or statement, disjunction, denying one alternative

Appears in past papers

2024