Convention
'Either A or B': if one is false, the other is true
Logical Reasoning • Conditional Statements
Statement
'Either A or B' says at least one of A and B happens. So if A does not happen, B must; and if B does not happen, A must. The valid pairs are (not A, then B) and (not B, then A). Knowing A happens does not tell whether B happens, because the statement does not say both cannot happen.
How to use it
- 1Name the two parts, A and B.
- 2A valid pair starts by denying one part and ends by stating the other.
- 3Reject any pair that starts by stating a part, or ends by denying one.
Worked example
'Either the shop is closed or the light is on.' The light is not on. What follows?
Step-by-step
- 1A: the shop is closed. B: the light is on.
- 2Not B is given, so A follows.
Why: At least one part must be true; the light part is false.
Answer
The shop is closed.
Watch out
Going from 'A is true' to 'B is false' is the trap: either-or forbids both being false, not both being true, unless the question says only one can happen.
Also known as
either or statement, disjunction, denying one alternative