Skip to content
Definition

'If A then B' gives 'if not B then not A', never 'if B then A'

Logical Reasoning • Conditional Statements

Statement

'If A is true, then B is true' only rules out one case: A true with B false. So whenever B is false, A must be false too (the contrapositive). But B can be true while A is false, so 'if B then A' (the converse) does not follow. To test a conclusion, look for a case that keeps every given rule and breaks the conclusion; if none exists, the conclusion follows.

How to use it

  1. 1Write each rule as the one case it forbids.
  2. 2For each conclusion, try to build a case that obeys every rule but breaks the conclusion.
  3. 3If you can build one, the conclusion does not follow. If every attempt breaks a rule, it does.

Worked example

Rule: if it rains, the match is cancelled. Does it follow that if the match is cancelled, it rained?

Step-by-step

  1. 1
    The rule forbids only: rain and the match played.
  2. 2
    No rain and match cancelled (say, for a strike) breaks no rule.

    Why: This case breaks the conclusion but keeps the rule.

Answer

No, it does not follow.

Watch out

Reading an if-then rule as if it worked in both directions is the trap.

Also known as

converse fallacy, contrapositive, if-then logic, implication

Appears in past papers

2023

2019